US vs Indian Television

October 1996
Many Indians who just land in US and start watching the advertisements, sitcoms and soaps on all the channels are puzzled by the programs. Why does everyone laugh at such a silly joke? Why is the ad so silly? How can someone use anti-campaigning to sell their product?

I have come up with some theory as to the state of affairs.

In India the people who buy Television are usually high earning people in the upper middle-class ( though this situation is rapidly changing ). In US almost every household has a TV. So it happens that the intellectual level of an average Indian having a Television is greater then that of an average American having a TV. (Note that it does not mean Indians are more intelligent than Americans - I have to be politically correct in US ). So the ads, sitcoms etc. are made w.r.t. this average person and the features in India end-up being less silly. Ref: The Good Guys Ad of VCR programming.

In terms of movies the opposite exactly works. Ever realized that 99% of art movies in India are never successful commercially !

The amount of brainwashing that one undergoes is clear from the fact that I am one of the avid watchers of Seinfeld and Home Improvement.

Just as an aside, here is Television put in Calvins' words -

Oh greatest of the mass media, thank you for elevating emotion, reducing the thought, and stifling imagination. Thank you for artificiality of quick solutions and for the insiduos manipulation of human desires for commercial purposes. This bowl of lukewarm tapioca represents my brain. I offer it in humble sacrifice. Bestow thy flickering light forever.

Back to My Ramblings
Back to Personal Stuff
Back to My HomePage

Comments to Kiran Bondalapati